April 2010 Archives

On February 23, 2010, The College of American Pathologists posted an article on its web site titled, "When a Rose Is Not a Rose."  The article discusses the problem of mislabeled specimens and the procedural improvements that can be made to prevent labeling errors.

The article explains that "...reporting a wrong result can have potentially devastating effects on the patient. This can be doubly true if there is a patient identification mix-up: one patient could receive the wrong medical or surgical treatment while another doesn't get the treatment he or she needs. Either situation can result in severe, irreversible consequences."  As a remedy to the various types of labeling errors it covers, the article offers several procedural improvements such as reviewing definitions, guidelines and the protocol for what to do when an error is detected. 

In December 2009, a report out of Obrezje, Slovenia revealed a lab switching error that resulted in the unnecessary complete stomach removal of a healthy woman, 50-year old Anica Kavecic.  Kavecic had no history of gastric problems, but when a biopsy showed a pervasive cancer in her stomach, she was urged to have an immediate and total gastrectomy. 

The diagnosis stunned both Kavecic and her family physician but the biggest shock came after the surgery when routine post-surgical tests revealed her stomach was cancer-free.  Her biopsy tissue samples had been switched with those of another patient, who in fact did have stomach cancer, resulting in the removal of her perfectly healthy stomach.